Promoting Human Rights & Rule of Law in South Africa
7 February, 2017
Thyolo – On Wednesday 8 February 2017, the Malawi High Court in Thyolo will hear arguments on an appeal of a man with albinism who argues that the sentence imposed on him for a minor offence was discriminatory.
What: Challenge against discriminatory sentencing of a man with albinism
Where: Malawi High Court sitting at the Magistrate’s Court in Thyolo
When: 8 February 2017
The appellant is a man with albinism who was charged with and pleaded guilty to being found drunk and incapable in a public place contrary to section 183(1) of the Malawi Penal Code. He was unrepresented at his trial. In determining his sentence, the Magistrates Court took into account the appellant’s albinism as an aggravating circumstance and sentenced him to a fine of MWK10,000.000 or six months’ imprisonment.
The appellant argues that the sentence imposed on him is unconstitutional and discriminatory on the basis of his albinism. He argues further that the Court impermissibly sought to use him as a scapegoat to deter other offenders despite that he was a first-time offender and failed to appreciate his albinism as a disability and as a mitigating circumstance. He argues that the sentence, being ten times the maximum penalty under the Penal Code and by imposing an impermissible custodial sentence for the offence in the alternative, is manifestly excessive and unlawful. He asks that his sentence be set aside.
The State agrees that the sentence imposed is excessive and ought to be set aside.
The appellant is represented by Mr Daniel Kalaya of Liberty Legal Consultants.
For more information:
Annabel Raw, Health Rights Lawyer, Southern Africa Litigation Centre (SALC): Tel: +27 (0)10 596 8538; Email: AnnabelR@salc.org.za
Victor Mhango, Executive Director, Centre for Human Rights Education, Advice and Assistance (CHREAA): Tel: +265 9999 52256, 888 95 22 56, email@example.com
Immaculate Maluza, Programmes Manager, CHREAA: Tel: +265 888 64 78 47, firstname.lastname@example.org
For Twitter updates: Follow_SALC #ThyoloAlbinism
Receive latest news from SALC
Latest Blog Posts
- PRESS RELEASE: BOTSWANA COURT OF APPEAL CURTAILS THE PRESIDENT’S POWER TO APPOINT HIGH COURT JUDGES
- SALC IN THE NEWS: SOUTH AFRICA PUTS UP SPIRITED DEFENCE AT ICC HEARING BUT ADVERSE FINDING LIKELY
- NEWS RELEASE ZAMBIA: SUPPORT INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT
- SALC IN THE NEWS: THE PRICE OF SHUNNING THE ICC
- SALC IN THE NEWS: WHY THE ICC SHOULD REFER SOUTH AFRICA TO THE UN SECURITY COUNCIL
- [RESOURCE MATERIALS] Removing Legal Barriers to Prison Health and Human Rights: Legal Training for African Lawyers
- [Workshop Report] Using complaints to address healthcare violations in Malawi
- PRESS RELEASE: NORTH GAUTENG HIGH COURT DELIVERS JUDGMENT ON ICC WITHDRAWAL CHALLENGE
- MENTAL DISORDERS ACT OF ZAMBIA MUST BE DECLARED NULL AND VOID
- SALC Anniversary Case Book
- CONFIDENTIALITY UNDER THE REFUGEES ACT- A SHIELD FOR SUSPECTED PERPETRATORS OF GRAVE CRIMES
- UNDERSTANDING THE ZIMBABWE TORTURE CASE
- SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENT IN ZIMBABWE TORTURE CASE: A VICTORY FOR LOCAL AND INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JUSTICE
- SALC LETTER TO SOUTH AFRICAN GOVERNMENT- SUPPORTING THE FIGHT AGAINST IMPUNITY AND ENCOURAGING INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY
- SALC IN THE NEWS: SOUTH AFRICA CAUSES BLUSHES IN HANDLING OF POLICY ON SYRIA