Promoting Human Rights & Rule of Law in South Africa
20 August, 2012
The SADC Summit of Heads of State and Government, conluded this weekend in Maputo, Mozambique, has effectively thrown the Tribunal on the rubbish heap, resolving that a new protocol for the Tribunal should be negotiated and “its mandate should be confined to interpretation of the SADC Treaty and Protocols relating to disputes between Member States”. That means no individual access will be permitted and SADC’s inhabitants will be denied justice.
The decision — indicated by a small paragraph at the end of the Summit’s final communiqué – is astounding not only because it so clearly violates the rule of law but because it completely disregards the recommendations of SADC’s own review process and those proposed by the Ministers of Justice and Attorney Generals.
See below a press release issued by the Southern Africa Litigation Centre (SALC) on the issue.
SADC LEADERS DEAL FATAL BLOW TO SADC TRIBUNAL:
SHOCK DECISION DENIES CITIZEN’S ACCESS TO COURT
Johannesburg, 20th August – Leaders of the Southern Africa Development Community (SADC) took a momentous decision in Maputo over the weekend – to shut the doors of the SADC Tribunal to the region’s citizens, preventing them from seeking justice and undermining the rule of law.
The shocking decision, which was taken at the annual summit of SADC Heads of State and Government in Maputo, not only left the Tribunal in limbo but also rendered it completely toothless by denying individual access to the court.
“The decision to deny the region’s inhabitants any access to the Tribunal is astounding and entirely without any lawful basis,” said Nicole Fritz, Director of the Southern Africa Litigation Centre (SALC). “Civil society groups were worried that SADC leaders would conspire to weaken the Tribunal but this is far worse than we had feared. SADC has destroyed it.”
The summit’s final communique explains that SADC leaders have “resolved that a new Protocol on the Tribunal should be negotiated and its mandate confined to interpretation of the SADC Treaty and Protocols relating to disputes between Member States.”
The original Tribunal Protocol made it clear that individuals also had access to the court – and all previous cases heard by the Tribunal had been brought by individuals.
“The decision flies in the face of the recommendations of both the SADC-instituted review of the Tribunal and SADC’s own Ministers of Justice and Attorneys General,” said Fritz. “It is also completely at odds with the best practice of other regional institutions and undermines the protection of human rights and hopes for future economic growth and development.”
The SADC Tribunal has been defunct for the past two years after SADC leaders demanded a review of its powers and functions, following a series of cases in which it had ruled against the Zimbabwean government.
Despite a campaign spearheaded by legal bodies, civil society organisations and individuals such as Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu, SADC’s leaders decided not to the revive the Tribunal immediately and to ensure that in future it will be little more than a shell.
“Our leaders have shown their contempt for all of us in southern Africa and for the rule of law,” said Fritz. “Not only did they deny the region’s citizens access to the Tribunal but Member States almost never bring legal cases against each other so the court will be a complete waste of taxpayers’ money.”
For more information, please contact:
Nicole Fritz, SALC Director; Off +27 11 587 5065; Cell +27 82 600 1028
Richard Lee, OSISA Communications Manager; Cell +27 83 2314192; Richardl@osisa.org
Receive latest news from SALC
Latest Blog Posts
- Civil Society calls on African States to Promote Justice for International Crimes at upcoming AU Summit
- Zambia: Activist defends right to freedom of expression
- An Exciting Week in Court for SALC: Freedom of Expression, the Right to Equality, Refugee Law and International Criminal Law
- Swaziland High Court resorts to jurisprudential gymnastics to justify conviction of editor
- Delegates at the National Constitution Convention in Zambia lose the plot on human rights
- SALC in the News: Krejcir Appeal Tests Rights of Refugees
- SALC in the News: Lesotho denies women right to be chiefs
- SALC IN THE NEWS: PAUL KASONKOMONA FIGHTS FOR FAIR TRIAL
- News Release: LESOTHO COURT FAILS WOMEN BY DENYING THEM THE RIGHT TO SUCCEED TO CHIEFTAINSHIP
- Media Advisory: FINAL ARGUMENTS IN SA HIGH COURT CHALLENGE TO REFUGEE STATUS OF CONTROVERSIAL RWANDAN GENERAL AND SUSPECTED WAR CRIMINAL
- Positive Reinforcement: Advocating for International Criminal Justice in Africa
- SALC IN THE NEWS: LEGABIBO CHALLENGES REFUSAL TO REGISTER ORGANISATION
- SALC HOSTS SENSITISATION MEETING OF SADC MEMBERS OF PARLIAMENT ON CERVICAL CANCER
- Not so Much a Surprise that the SADC Tribunal was Disbanded but that it was Formed at All
- African Leaders embarrassing African Court judges